How to know when bulk fermentation is done
Last updated

Bulk fermentation is the first long rise of the whole dough, after the mix and before shaping. You can tell when it’s done by looking at the dough and handling it. Below are the four signs to look for, why clock time alone misleads, where the sources disagree, and what to do when you can’t tell.
When is bulk fermentation done?
Bulk fermentation is usually done when the dough has risen about 30 to 50%, has a domed top, shows bubbles at the edges, and jiggles when you shake the container. A time estimate only tells you when to start checking. If you’re not sure, give it 15 to 30 minutes and look again, as The Perfect Loaf advises.
The four signs that bulk fermentation is done
These are the four things Crustworthy’s end-of-bulk check asks about. No single one is enough on its own. Look for most of them together.
1. A rise of about 30 to 50%
Before bulk starts, put the dough in a straight-sided, see-through container and mark the level with tape or a marker, so you can judge the rise against the mark. We use about 30 to 50% as the default. The Perfect Loaf’s beginner recipe gives a range of 20 to 50%, and other sources aim higher or lower, as the section on disagreements below explains.
2. A domed top
At the start, the dough lies flat or a little slack in the container. As it ferments, the surface rounds up and curves where it meets the sides. A flat top usually means it needs longer.
3. Bubbles at the edges
Look through the side of the container and at the top surface. You want to see bubbles in the dough along the edges.
4. A jiggle
Give the container a gentle shake. Dough that is ready wobbles as a whole, a bit like set jelly. Dough that needs longer feels dense and moves less.
The poke test is for the final proof
You may have read about poking the dough. That test belongs to the final proof, the rise after shaping, not to bulk. The Perfect Loaf’s sign of a ready proof is an indent that springs back about halfway. During bulk, use the four signs above.
Why the clock alone misleads
The same dough moves at very different speeds in different kitchens, for several reasons.
- Temperature. The Perfect Loaf’s dough temperature article gives about 4 to 4.5 hours of bulk for dough at 75°F, and 6 to 8 hours in a cool kitchen of about 68°F. Our guide to a sourdough schedule for a cool kitchen covers the slow end.
- The rise you aim for. At 80°F, The Perfect Loaf gives 3 to 3.5 hours, while The Sourdough Journey reports about 5.5 hours for its dough. That’s almost twice as long at the same temperature, and most of the gap is that the two aim for different rises.
- Flour and water. The Perfect Loaf warns that the right rise depends on the dough. A white dough at 70% hydration may roughly double, while a whole-wheat dough at 100% hydration may rise only 20 to 30%, and both can be ready.
- The starter. The Perfect Loaf notes that an overripe levain speeds things up. It doesn’t say by how much.
King Arthur Baking’s guide to bulk fermentation gives 3 to 5 hours at room temperature as typical, and then tells you to judge the dough by how it looks and feels: plan around the time range, and let the dough’s signs decide.
Where the sources disagree
The biggest disagreement is the rise to aim for. Across the sources we read, targets run from 20 to 75%, depending on the method.
- The Perfect Loaf’s beginner recipe: 20 to 50%.
- The Sourdough Journey, for dough that goes into the fridge straight after bulk: about 30% for warm dough at 80°F, and about 75% for cooler dough at 70°F. It adds that if you will bake from room temperature instead, you should aim higher.
Warm dough can stop earlier because it is still rising fast. The Sourdough Journey found that warm dough rises about 20% an hour near the end of bulk, and cool dough about 10%. Dough that goes into the fridge also keeps rising while it cools. By its figures, dough cooling from 80°F to 70°F rose by up to about 20% in roughly the first hour. So a warm dough headed for the fridge can stop at a lower mark and still finish well.
Pick one recipe and its target, and stick with it for a few bakes. The Sourdough Journey suggests moving the target by about 10 after a bake that came out under- or over-proofed. Keep a note of the rise you stopped at and the kitchen temperature, so each bake teaches you something about your own dough.
When you’re not sure
- If it hasn’t risen enough, has a flat top and few bubbles, give it 15 to 30 minutes and look again. The Perfect Loaf’s advice is the same: a little more time, then check.
- If it’s domed, bubbly and jiggly, at or near your target, it’s done. Move on to shaping.
- If it’s very bubbly, or starting to sag or collapse, it has gone past ready. Shape it now.
If you are going to put the shaped dough in the fridge overnight, err on the early side, since it will keep rising for a while as it cools.
Two common questions
Does the fridge stop fermentation? It slows it right down once the dough is cold, but not straight away. The Sourdough Journey puts it at about 12 hours for dough to cool all the way to 37°F, and estimates that at 37°F a full day in the fridge is worth at most about 30 minutes of peak bulk activity.
Can my fridge be too warm? Yes. The Sourdough Journey warns that more than 12 hours above 42°F tends to overproof the dough, and that some fridges run as warm as 45°F. A cheap fridge thermometer settles it.
Choosing an app
If you’re choosing an app to help with this, our comparison of sourdough apps sets ten other apps beside ours, and says where another one is the better choice.
Want times for your own kitchen? Try the free schedule calculator.
Sources
Crustworthy: Sourdough Planner
Coming to the App Store in December 2026.
14-day free trial, then $39.99 a year. Also $9.99 a month, $4.99 a week, or $79.99 once.
The app has no free tier. The calculator and guides on this site are free.